Memories of Change - Ancient Texts and Geographic changes

 

Synopsis

A journey from Kashmir to Dwaraka with detours to Hastinapur and on the banks of Saraswati River ! History and Science, seemingly at two ends of the spectrum, when studied together, provide us with brilliant insights. This article explores geographical events mentioned in ancient historical texts and now proven by science.  

The vast landscape of Ladakh Himalaya is a wonder in itself. The barren desert, laced with even barren mountains reaching the sky, with a background of even higher mountains covered in snow! The green bushes and poplars giving a respite to eyes along with pristine blue ribbons of celestial rivers. And in that cold desert, you do find the bluest of the blue lakes gleaming in moonlight and morning sun.

But the water is salty. And on the ground, you are guaranteed to find shells and cones. Are we on a seashore?   Actually, we are standing   on a sea shore whose waves stopped lapping millions of years ago. Modern scientific discoveries tell us that the Himalaya Mountain range is formed due to collision of 2 plates and shrinking of the sea and lifting up of the seabed.

Indian subcontinent has several such mysteries and moments tucked away in its geographical expanse. This geography is home to home to millions of people as well.

Children of this homeland nurtured a continuous civilization which flourished over several millennia. Not surprisingly, the oral and written histories, legends and mythologies of India are humongous. Thankfully, our ancestors painstakingly noted the dynasties, events, wars and also geography, seasons, natural calamities and astronomical data.

Figure 1 Slide by Author

There are many memories in our historical literature which can now be verified with research using science and technology. History and Science, seemingly at two ends of the spectrum, when studied together, provide us with brilliant insights about us Humans  and our surroundings. Scientific research in last few decades confirms what was traditionally known to Indians, as part of Sanatan Hindu scriptures.

Dwaraka of Shrikrishna

Land of Saurashtra in western India, nearing Arabian Sea is sacred because of presence of Dwaraka, a city established by Shrikrishna as per Mahabharat. As of now, based on traditions, we find 2 locations for Dwarka. One is in western Saurashtra near Gulf of Kutch, and the adjoining island is known as Bet Dwarka. The Other Dwarka is in southeast Saurashtra and is known as Mool Dwarka near the town of Kodinar. Bet Dwarka is also known by its ancient name of Shankhodhar, which means  island in shape of Konch.  

Now the marine excavations were done at both places, near Bet Dwaraka and Mool Dwarka. Both excavations have exhibited continuous settlement for thousands of years. The artefacts found in the sea include, well cut stone slabs, stone holes as anchors and circular stone structures  which could be pillar bases. These discoveries done from 1980 onwards tell us about part of Indian subcontinent which is submerged now was once a thriving city. Rising sea levels in last few millennia must have covered the ground which was once part of human settlement. [Ref1]

Figure 2- 3 possible Locations of Dwarka – Courtesy Google Earth

 

This brings us to the memory recorded in Mahabharat, Harivansha and Bhagvat Puran. Harivansha and also other Puran books tell us about a once beautiful but now ruined city of Kushsthali near the western sea in the vicinity of Raivatak mountain. Shri Krishna decided to establish Dwaravati or Dwaraka at the location of Kushsthali and in addition, asked the Sea lord to give away some more land. The Sea obliged and Dwaraka, one of the most beautiful cities, was built on recovered land as well. 

As mentioned in Mahabharat, after a few years, the sea engulfed and swallowed Dwarka. The description in Mahabharat is a matter of fact!  Krishna’s Dwaraka was captured by sea in front of the eyes of Dwaraka citizens who were led by Arjuna to evacuate the city as per Shri Krishna’s orders. 

Some experts have pointed out that this Dwaraka could be near Prabhas teerth near Somnath, and that could be probable third location of Dwaraka.

In any case, the Coast of Saurashtra, when explored with marine archeology, has given ample proof of settlements dating to second or third millennia before today which are submerged under sea now. This coincides with the description of sea capturing the Dwarka which was a costal island as per scriptures. This could be result of massive Tsunami or rising sea levels. [Ref 6]

 

Hastinapur of Kaurav and Pandav

Hastinapur is capital of Kurus as mentioned in Mahabharata. It is on the banks of Ganga River. Vayu Puran and Matsya Puran mention that Hastinapur had to face floods and hence the capital shifted to Kosambi during reign of Nichakshu, the fourth Kuru king after Janmejay. 

Figure 3 -Hastinapur Location - and Ganga river - Courtesy Google Earth

Now let us see what scientific discoveries tell us. Hastinapur even today is on the bank of Ganga River in northwestern Uttar Pradesh. A channel of Ganga close by is known is Budhi Ganga which could be original bed of Ganga River in ancient years. Archeologists have carried out a lot of excavation work at Hastinapur since 1950. Dr B B Lal, one of the renowned archeologists, is credited with the extensive excavation of layers at Hastinapur. The archeological evidence suggests a gap in settlements. There is also evidence of Ganga flood water in the soil found between two settlement layers. This relates well with what Mahabharat told us years back. [Ref2]

 

Saraswati River

Mahabharat also tells us about drying up of the river Saraswati. We have known Saraswati River since Rigveda, the oldest of the texts mentions that Saraswati is largest and grandest of the rivers. Saraswati flows from mountains to the sea, and we also know of several ‘Teerth’ on its bank. However today, we do not see Saraswati flowing with all its might where it was supposed to flow which is Haryana, Rajasthan and Gujrat. Instead, we see the desert of Thar and water strapped land of Gujarat.

The scientific discoveries in the last century have proven that part of present-day Rajasthan is covered in paleochannels (water-soaked tracks of underground soil, visible through satellite imaging). [Ref3] There have been other discoveries which conclude that there must have been a large Himalayan River flowing through this northwestern India and reaching Arabian sea. The dates of ‘Grand Saraswati’ are varying depending on the research papers.  However, denial of existence of Saraswati River in Indian geography is no more possible.  [Ref4]

Figure 4 Satellite Image of Sarasati Paleochannels as per  https://bhuvan-app1.nrsc.gov.in/

Now back to Mahabharata, where the ‘’Itihas’’ mentions about Vinashan, a place where Saraswati has vanished. Not only that, Mahabharat mentions about the reappearance of Saraswati at some places on its course.  Balaram, Shri Kirshna’s brother traverses the Saraswati as part of Parikrama and Mahabharat text brings information about several places /Teerths on the Saraswati River.

Figure 5-Teerth on Saraswati river – Courtesy Google Earth

Matsya Puran has a story about Saraswati river being given a task to carry the fierce Vadavanal , the Mega Fire into the western sea. Due to this Saraswati goes underground carrying the mighty fire. The task itself may indicate, drying up of Saraswati.

The later discoveries have also inferred that Satluj and Yamuna were the primary tributaries of Saraswati. Due to tectonic movements, these rivers turned away and that impacted Saraswati waters to a large extent. May be Triveni Sangam at Prayag which honorably includes Saraswati brings us the cultural memory of Saraswati whose water is now captured by Yamuna and brought to Ganga!

 

Kashmir  - Satisar and Satidesh

Kashmir, the sacred land of Kashyap Rishi, Shaiva philosophy has one of most intriguing stories to tell.

Figure 6 - Dal Lake, Srinagar – Courtesy - Author

The valley of Kashmir, surrounded by Himalayan Mountain peaks was once a massive lake. Scientists have discovered ‘Karewa’, the local name of flat elevated land, show soil deposits of lakebed and glacial feed. Also, the direction of Karewas slope is in particular direction denoting the flow of water. It is worthwhile to note that land in the valley has a lot of water content and it is very fertile owing to the fact that it was once a lakebed. A huge lake, tilted northward, eventually found an opening at Baramulla or Varahmul as known to ancient Indians, on the western wall and drained, also forming Vitasta to carve its course out of the valley. The discovery tells us that this event must have happened 85,000 years before present. [Ref5]

 

What is surprising is that this scientific discovery is corroborated by an ancient text called Neelmat Puran

Neelmat Puran, is a Sthal-Puran or location-history of Kashmir.  As per the Puranic verses, Satisar was the big lake occupying the Sati-Desh, which is Kashmir valley for as long as five Manvantar.

Rishi Kashyap drained the lake and Jalodbhav – The water Born Asur dwelling inside and troubling all, was killed. Lake was drained by destroying the mountain wall and creating an opening at Varahmool, one which looks like the mouth of a wild boar, another incarnation of Bhagwan Vishnu. The lake drained, the demon was demolished, and land formed to be inhabited by people and Nag families, supposed to be original inhabitants. There is a reason why we find several place names postfixed with Nag in Kashmir like, Anantnag, Verinag etc.  Also, we find several lakes in the valley, such as Wular, Manasbal and Dal Lake, probably remnants of the original mega lake. Now, how the Nilmat Puran described an event which might have occurred geologically 85,000 years ago is a great riddle to solve.

There are many such hidden truths or insights in our ancient texts. The story of floods which drowned the entire world and threatened the existence of the living world is also there in all cultures. We have Manu as the survivor and protector and his boat whereas in Bible, there is Noah and its arc!

Apart from the geophysical events, there are many such astronomical and even sociological events recorded in various scriptures and texts which provide us with a more informed glimpse into our past. Corroborating them with scientific discoveries in recent times throws open a wide range of possibilities regarding the course of history as we know.

 

References

• Ref1  - https://www.nodc.noaa.gov/archive/arc0001/9900162/2.2/data/0-data/jgofscd/htdocs/organisation/archaeology/Dwarka.htm
• Ref 2- https://www.worldwidejournals.com/paripex/article/exploration-on-old-bed-of-ganges-in-hastinapur/MTE5MDY=/?is=1

·         Ref 3 -  Satellite image-based mapping of the Saraswati-Drishadvati palaeochannel system was carried out by Ghose et al. (1979),

• Ref4 - The Lost Saraswati River of Northwestern Indian Plains: Status and way forward - by H.S.Saini 1 , Apurva Alok2 , N.C. Pant2 – Critical examination of Saraswati Paleochannels ( 2019)

·         Ref 5 - The Northern Neolithic of the Western Himalayas: New Research in the Kashmir Valley Alison Bettsa , Mumtaz Yatoob , Michael Spatea,⁎ , James Fraserc , Zahoor Kalood , Younus Rashide , Anil Pokhariaf , Guilin Zhang

·         Ref 6 - https://geoscienceletters.springeropen.com/articles/10.1186/2196-4092-1-3

Published previously at

https://esamskriti.com/e/History/Indian-History/A-Journey-from-Kashmir-Valley-to-Dwarka-via-Hastinapur-and-Saraswati-River-1.aspx?fbclid=IwY2xjawQXlfBleHRuA2FlbQIxMQBzcnRjBmFwcF9pZBAyMjIwMzkxNzg4MjAwODkyAAEeBAtf23nD2BIuYyvFagrpwsAtIsDpk-_DHTkWNU8u6IjfDF0TvZ54HT3zibo_aem_K8WUlkv-EouFPM6xU4Ckrw